Do Influencers Have An Impact On Everyday Life?

Introduction

The essay explores what kind of changes influencers make upon people’s lives. Influencers have become very popular within the past few years, they are becoming conversation starters. There are people who think influencers only make others lives worse and cause mental health problems. On the other hand, there are those who believe influencers have no downsides. The essay will review both sides of the arguments, looking at the changes and impacts that influencers have on society. This includes looking at financial changes where the study will focus on discovering whether influencers impact spending habits and to what extent. There are lots of companies that are increasing their financial spending on influencers, which will be looked into. The financial aspect is important because those most affected by influencers financially may not realise it. It will also look at the mental and emotional effect influencers have on people. Are there only negatives to the story? Many people enjoy watching influencers, they can help inform and even improve mental health. These positive effects are being clouded by the negatives of other influencers, through the likes of political statements or false information.

Influencers face a lot of hate and negative comments which clearly suggests that people are getting hurt by the content being put out. These comments are also affecting influencers, which leads to changes in the type of content they put out. Influencers who receive hate comments will try to avoid doing things that led to these comments. Could this lead to more repetitive and conservative content? There are many new influencers who became known through TikTok, they are receiving negative comments too but do not have the same level of experience and money to deal with this negativity. This could lead to an increase in mental health problems.

Finance dollar sign
Do Influencers Affect Financial Choices?

Influencers are becoming a common source of entertainment and information. They have become conversation starters. But does this mean our lives are being changed because of such influence? Would you recommend a product which you heard about from an influencer? There are many people who hold high faith in influencers and that try out new products because of them. This shift has created a new digital age where a lot of shared content has some form of marketing strategy embedded into it. Think of posts where clothes worn by the influencer have hyperlinks to a shop. This has led to the exposure of products and increased brand awareness which is huge within the digital era. Research states that 92% of customers would follow an influencers choices compared to advertisements or celebrity endorsements. This shows that influencers are becoming the most popular form of endorsement, which also confirms their rise in entertainment. But it is important to know how far this influence reaches. Many articles point to the same conclusion, "40% of people say they have purchased a product online as a result of seeing it being used by an influencer on social media” (Saleh, 2019). There are many people who are susceptible to influencers and their effects. In the UK alone there are “53 million active social media users as of January 2021. That translates to a social media penetration rate of 77.9 percent of the population” (Johnson, 2020). So if these 40% purchases translated to the UK population, there would be over 21 million purchases as a result of influencers in the UK alone.

Influencer marketing strategies can be beneficial to small businesses who would otherwise not be noticed. By partnering with influencers, the company has someone trustworthy who will immediately improve brand perception and awareness. This is because there is already a trust built between an influencer and their followers which could translate to consumer action when the brands are supported. Another benefit for companies using influencers is that by choosing them, they are able to reach highly specific audiences. By choosing influencers, an organic advertisement experience is created because ads are being integrated into the viewers feed rather than being displayed as pop-ups.

Lush decided to go off social media in October 2021. The company stated that the “serious effects of social media were barely being acknowledged” and that social media channels “need to start listening to the reality of how they're impacting people's mental health and the damage that they're causing.” They say that social media should be “more about passions and less about likes.” The interesting part is how they want to change their approach. Instead of using social media, the company plans to “personify the brand” by using influencers to spread word about them and their products. This is an interesting approach because by doing this they say they will reach audiences on a more personal level, where they won’t be forced to pay to have their content displayed in the form of ads. Lush say they will lose a predicted “£10m in sales” by reducing their social media presence.

Influencers Are Also Affected By This Too

Influencers try to entertain people, but they can receive a lot of hate for it. They can receive a lot of negative comments which are often unjustified only because others resent them for things like status or money. Their own mental health is also being affected as a result of them being an influencer. Charli D’Amelio is one example of this hate. She is only 17 years old and has received many angry comments over the past year who are upset that she’s become famous for her dance videos. These sorts of incidents are common amongst influencers and it makes their self-esteem and mental health worse than it would otherwise be. Another is 19-year-old TikToker Spencewuah who just announced he would be taking a break from TikTok after facing backlash over his video. The problem with TikTok is that the site depends on mid-size creators yet they do not offer the kind of money needed for such influencers to insulate themselves from those followings. So they get famous because of their videos but are unaware of what comes with such fame. The problem is that TikTok is the big current trend so lots of people, both adults and teenagers, become mid-size creators without any support creating a negative atmosphere of fame which they can’t find their way around. From a conducted survey, “47% of surveyed influencers felt their job as an influencer had an impact on their mental health” while “32% believes the platform gave them a negative impact on body image” (Leighton, n.d.). Another issue is that many influencers are afraid of branching out from whatever the algorithm decides it likes in fear of becoming irrelevant. This results in repetitive content which is fuelled by an algorithm, this algorithm is bad as it results in less innovation and creativity from influencers. This has negative effects on influencers’ well-being because the main reason they want to become influencers is creativity. 24% of the “younger generations are drawn to creative pursuits and crafting content that supports their creativity” (Mediakix, 2018).

The most common form of posting is through either the video or image format. On Twitter alone, tweets that “include images or videos are 394% more likely to be retweeted” (xperiencify.com, n.d.). So in a lot of this content, people get to see the influencers’ environments. The lesser-known influencers want to create attractive posts with nice backgrounds, fancy brands and they want to follow the trend; they are also seeing the super-famous influencers and start thinking that having super expensive gadgets and houses is a must for content creation. But they don’t have the funds to live this kind of lifestyle. They also get pressured by the negative comment about their cheap apartment or cheap equipment and through these comments, influencers are almost bullied into spending money that they don’t have just to stay relevant. The websites say it themselves, one of the best ways to increase media engagement; by creating original and engaging visuals. There are quite a few ways to do this, but most of them require unique (read expensive) products, locations or decor to serve as backgrounds. Like influencer Mondalek says, “Someone is purchasing something you can’t purchase or making connections you haven’t made yet. It’s the rat-race lifestyle boiled down into the palm of your hand, and sometimes it feels inescapable.”

Finance dollar sign
Influencers are creating disinformation

Disinformation comes from many sources and sadly one of these sources are influencers. There are many examples, the most well-known is relating to politics but the most recent relates to the Coronavirus pandemic. The Centre for Countering Digital Hate has conducted research which led them to the conclusion that most of the vaccine disinformation has been created by influencers. The so-called ‘disinformation dozen’ are responsible for up to 65% of anti-vaccine content that has been created. The ‘disinformation dozen’ consists of 12 people and has resulted in the removal of more than 16 million pieces of content which violate policies on Facebook alone. The whole following of this anti-vaccine movement has reached a critical amount of people, according to the research “anti-vaccine activists on Facebook, YouTube, Instagram and Twitter reach more than 59 million followers” (www.cbsnews.com, n.d.). That is how widespread the movement has become as a result of very few people who created fake scientific statistics.

Another problem is that influencers are being paid to spread disinformation relating to the covid vaccines. This is an issue because it shows how a worldwide crisis is being monetised even though the vaccines are meant to help people. This whole issue of disinformation is very important because it shows just how much influencers can change people’s opinions on a global scale. They are being affected mentally because this issue is on their mind constantly, they are being affected physically because they could become sick and they are being affected financially either through medical bills or by supporting this.

TikTok

The new wave of influencers are creating mass changes. There are ordinary people with random videos who are getting hundreds, thousands and millions of views without much of a following before this occurrence. One example is Lyn Lapid, who made a TikTok about a “disappointing experience she had with a producer when she was first trying to get her music out.” The video got 50 million views helping the 18-year-old release that video as a single, even though she never had this number of views before. The new social media site has allowed for many changes and like seen with Lapid, TikTok can offer a new way for independent musicians to go viral. This means a new future; one where anyone can become content creators on their phones with little equipment. This also changes the content that we see, it makes the content more unique as anyone can get through the algorithm and it changes the type of people we see in our feeds. The introduction of TikTok has also led to increased activism; people are spreading awareness about issues like climate change, mixing political statements with goofy videos and spreading knowledge about things such as different cultures. Now, all the other media sites think about Instagram and its new stories feature. Whether for good or for bad, TikTok will most probably live on just as many other social media sites do, but whether it remains as popular as it is now remains a question.

Influencer’s Link To Mental Health

Influencers have the power to impact a person's behaviour, mood and choices. They are very powerful because of their ability to entertain people while also being relatable to the audience on a more personal level. This means that the audience is more willing to listen to influencers and follow their opinions, treating the influencer as an extension of their own personality. If the influencer has a close following, then people who support them may buy into their products and show them off. Things like personalised shirts are one of the most common forms of extending one's personality to that of the influencer. The reason this happens is because people are happy being a part of that influencer’s community, which shows their positive effect. A current trend is exposing fake beauty where social media filters alter someone’s face to make them look perfect. The trend is called “filtered reality” and it aims to show people they are good enough without alterations, but the real goal is to raise awareness and help raise people’s self-image. It is an example of a positive coming out of a negative. Although it shows progress and is making the good change, this shouldn’t be necessary in the first place because these filters and trends are a by-product of influencers. A bit ironic but to expose this filtered reality, people have decided to use a filter for this purpose. One which shows half of the person’s actual face and another half which shows just how much a “beauty” filter can alter someone’s look. This is a good beginning that could lead to more movements like this that could bring balance to the social media environment.

Influencers tend to have a niche when posting which means they create communities for people of similar interests. It also means more information and knowledge is shared between viewers and the influencer, for example if the viewer is passionate about art then the influencer who creates art would make them aware of different techniques or equipment which someone new would not be aware of. This works both ways, sometimes it is the community that would make the influencer aware of better techniques for certain processes. People can also share their opinions in the form of comments which brings the community together. The feeling of being part of a community leads to positive mental health and emotional wellbeing. It provides a sense of belonging and can bring extra meaning and purpose to everyday life. On the other side of the spectrum, commenting on posts can be very damaging. People who write hateful comments know they will not face consequences for doing so, which increases such wrongdoing. Only someone who knows and hates the influencer would be willing to write such comments.

This is devastating for influencers because they rely on comments and feedback to keep going and to create relevant content. A study conducted in Poland states that the most common reason for “ people using hate speech on the internet” is “lack of satisfaction with one’s life” (Statista, n.d.) which amounted to 37% of the respondents’ replies. Like Roosevelt once said, “comparison is a thief of joy.” People who constantly follow an influencer want to become like them, which has negative effects as they try to follow trends and change themselves to live up to the standards of society. Take, for example, the lip augmentation trend which was made popular by Kylie Jenner. It was a “challenge” which had people, mostly teenagers, “using shot glasses to try to plump up their lips” for no other reason than social media attention and views. The real-life result of this though; anything from swelling to burst blood vessels and permanent damage.

Mental health- heart, brain and head image
Virtual Influencers
Website screenshot

The rapid development of engineering, artificial intelligence and science have led us to a new wave of influencers. These are virtual influencers, they serve different purposes depending on the influencer and are leading a new kind of innovation within the marketing realm. Virtual influencers are “fictional computer generated ‘people’ who have the realistic characteristics, features and personalities of humans” (Ammann, n.d.). Not so long ago those robots taking over the world movies were just fiction. But these virtual influencers aren’t, yet, creating content on their own. Behind each of them are “brands and individuals with a keen eye for technology – who remain faceless” (influencermatchmaker.co.uk, n.d.). But they are already being mixed up and thought to be real individuals by some. One of the most followed virtual influencers is Lil Miquela and she has 3.1 million followers. She looks like a real person, but she can also be compared to Samsung’s AR emoji tool. With this AR, someone can easily take real pictures with only their face being replaced by the AR emoji face. Lil Miquela has held many collaborations with the two most notable being with Calvin Klein and Prada. The importance of these collaborations is immense, because they led her to fame but also opened the gateway of virtual influencers being used as a way of marketing.

The benefits of virtual influencer marketing is that companies have full creative control over what content they want to share and how. Brands can imagine, create and invent new ways of sharing their products/services. Another benefit of virtual influencer marketing is that they hold less risk – they won't have strong opinions in subjects such as politics which means they can't damage a brand through such matters. Virtual influencers could become a cheaper method of advertising than real influencers and virtual influencers won't suffer negative impacts stemming from negative comments and hate from fans. There are positives in this situation however. Recently YouTubers were approached by a “mysterious marketing agency secretly offering to pay social media stars to spread disinformation about covid-19 vaccines” (The YouTubers who blew the whistle on an anti-vax plot, 2021). That plan backfired as influencers went public about the attempt to recruit them. This is great because it allowed the public to see that there are masterminds behind this movement who are set on changing peoples opinions regardless of cost. There are other influencers who are encouraging people to take the vaccine which is a lot more common than influencers who promote the opposite so it is a matter of the few making a bad name for the good ones.

Travel App Screens

Conclusion

We know that influencers are making a change to peoples lives. They have a huge impact on spending habits where many people are making purchases simply because an item is being advertised by an influencer. We know that influencer marketing became popular in 2016 and has continued to rise annually. From this we can conclude that influencer marketing is effective and that it will continue to advance as companies continue to increase their budget for this purpose. Influencer marketing has changed the game in the sense that it enables small and new companies to spread much faster as through affirmation and word of mouth, or word of the internet. People are being affected mentally and emotionally. People can laugh, cry or cheer for an influencer whether that be in videos or through posts. But it also means people begin to have faith in that influencer when it comes to different opinions like politics or brands. The new “filtered reality” trends shows that some influencers are ready to make a change for the better by exposing the unrealistic marketing and posts that are being shared by others. Influencers get a lot of hate on their content.

Commenting is the most common type of negativity and leads to changes in influencers’ lives, leading to changes in content and could cause mental health problems. Social media algorithm is responsible for a reduction in creativity as influencers are afraid to branch out in fear that the content won’t be found or will be irrelevant. Influencers are creating disinformation. The most recent example being with covid vaccines although in this case, the influencers creating this are a minority. This is creating a bad image for other influencers who do not participate in such practice. Although there are no statistics about the amount of influencers creating disinformation, it could be said that this is a minority as most want to focus on what they enjoy. TikTok has created a wave where new people are quickly gaining popularity which leads to new challenges as they are unaware of how to navigate ‘fame’ and the negativity that comes with it. This new wave has allowed people such as music artists to make their passion a reality without the necessity of money to get into the spotlight. It has also led to more activism about topics like culture. Virtual influencers are also gaining popularity, they are already being used for marketing so the future for real influencers could be very different than it is today.

The future of influencers could be much different with the development of virtual influencers. They could become the primary source of followings which would result in less everyday influencers, instead people would depend on artificial influencers. The future of influencers could also change depending on what changes social media sites make to their policies that could change the type of content that can be created. Trends could also change future developments, for example with TikTok the short reel video trend became a huge success and it changed the type of content we view. A new social media platform could also emerge which would change the content being shared and how this is being done. The future could also stay similar though, until virtual influencers are able to think independently and create trends then real people will still be the main source of social influence.

A photo of myself

Bibliography

Filtered Reality. (n.d.). Seeing Ourselves Through Technology.

BenchmarkONE. (2020). 5 Benefits of Influencer Marketing For Your Small Business. [online]

Fastenau, J. (2018). Under the Influence: The Power of Social Media Influencers. [online] Medium.

Geyser, W. (2018). What Is Influencer Marketing? An in Depth Look at Marketing’s Next Big Thing. [online] Influencer Marketing Hub.

Blogger, S.R. | F.T. (n.d.). The Positive Impact of Social Media Influencers. [online] SamanthaRickelton.com.

Awan, I. (2020). Social media helps reveal people’s racist views – so why don’t tech firms do more to stop hate speech? [online] The Conversation.

Affinio (2016). The Dark Side of Being A Social Media Influencer. [online] Medium.

Your Wish Bag. (2021). Negative Effects Of Social Media Influencers On Youth. [online]

Rusmanica, T. (n.d.). How social media influencers affect your life • Bigwave Marketing. [online]

Tankovska, H. (2019). UK: Social Media Penetration 2019 | Statista. [online] Statista.

Saleh, K. (2019). How Social Media Influencers Are Impacting Online Buying Decisions- Statistics and Trends [Infographic]. [online] Invespcro.com.

Digital Marketing Institute (2018). 20 Influencer Marketing Statistics that Will Surprise You. [online] Digital Marketing Institute.

Stern, A. (2021). Influencer Marketing Trends Impacting Mental Health. [online] [Talking Influence].

Writer, S. (n.d.). How Influencer Marketing Benefits Small Businesses. [online] www.smallbusinessrainmaker.com.

Wikipedia. (2021). Lip augmentation. [online]

Plastic Surgery Blog | New York Facial Plastic Surgeon Blog. (2016). Kylie Jenner Lip Challenge Trend | Unsafe Lip Augmentation. [online]

mastersofmedia.hum.uva.nl. (2021). Kids see Kidfluencers; a qualitative study on the negative effects of child influencers on YouTube | Masters of Media. [online]

Karim, F., Oyewande, A., Abdalla, L.F., Chaudhry Ehsanullah, R. and Khan, S. (2020). Social Media Use and Its Connection to Mental Health: A Systematic Review. Cureus, [online] 12(6).

NeoReach | Influencer Marketing Platform. (2020). Top 10 Mental Health Influencers on Social Media | NeoReach Blog. [online]

Barker, S. (2018). 85 Influencer Marketing Statistics That Will Surprise You in 2018 (Updated September). [online] Shane Barker.

We Are Lush. (n.d.). Lush is becoming anti-social. [online]

McCarthy, J. (2019). Lush abandons social media: it’s “getting harder” to talk to customers. [online] The Drum.

BBC News. (2021). Lush to stop some social media until it’s “safer.” [online]

TechJury. (2019). 21+ Influencer Marketing Statistics to AMAZE You in 2020. [online]

Hashtag Legend. (2019). Insta-haters: The downside of being an influencer. [online]

Bailis, R. (2019). Influencer Marketing Statistics in 2019 (Trends + Key Takeaways). [online] The BigCommerce Blog.

www.psychologytoday.com. (n.d.). Social Media Affects Influencers’ Mental Health | Psychology Today United Kingdom. [online]

Leighton, H. (n.d.). Influencers Admit That Instagram Is Bad For Body Image, Mental Health, Study Shows. [online] Forbes.

Gritters, J. (2019). How Instagram takes a toll on influencers’ brains. [online] the Guardian.

Dexerto. (2021). Charli D’Amelio admits that it’s “difficult” to enjoy TikTok fame with constant hate.

Jennings, R. (2021). The influencers are burned out, too. [online] Vox.

www.easel.ly. (2019). Text vs. Images: Which Content Format is Effective? [online]

Insights into social media marketing & management | Statusbrew. (2019). 100 Social Media Statistics For 2020 + [Infographic] | Statusbrew. [online]

Shane Barker. (2020). 10 Best Ways to Increase Social Media Engagement in 2021. [online]

Mediakix. (2018). Why 75% Of Children Are Dead Set On Becoming A YouTuber. [online]

influencermatchmaker.co.uk. (n.d.). Virtual Influencers: What Are They & How Do They Work? [online]

Anon, (2021). Do virtual influencers have a future in influencer marketing? - TrendMainia. [online]

Samsung uk. (n.d.). What is AR (Augmented Reality) Emoji and how do I use it? [online]

eu.community.samsung.com. (2020). Create your AR Emoji. [online]

Wikipedia. (2021). Miquela. [online]

Statista. (n.d.). Poland: reasons for hateful comments online 2021. [online]

Covid-19: How did a volunteer panel react when we showed them an anti-vax video? (2021). BBC News. [online] 14 Feb.

Covid vaccine: Social media urged to remove “disinfo dozen.” (2021). BBC News. [online] 26 Mar.

The Disinformation Dozen. 2021. [online]

Hussain, A., Ali, S., Ahmed, M. and Hussain, S. (2018). The anti-vaccination movement: A regression in modern medicine. Cureus, [online] 10(7).

First Draft. (2020). Online influencers have become powerful vectors in promoting false information and conspiracy theories. [online]

Santillo, E. (2021). Social media influencers rewarded for posting “outrageous” conspiracy theories. [online] HullLive.

ProMarket. (2021). Influencers are Paid to Spread Political Messages, Disinformation. [online]

text.npr.org. (n.d.). Just 12 People Are Behind Most Vaccine Hoaxes On Social Media, Research Shows. [online]

First Draft. (n.d.). Protect your voice: a toolkit for influencers and celebrities in Australia and New Zealand. [online]

Greenspan, R.E. (n.d.). Celebrities, politicians, and influencers are largely accountable for the spread of false coronavirus information, according to a new study. [online] Insider.

The New Daily. (2021). Facebook, Instagram influencers targeted in misinformation campaign. [online]

Galer, S.S. (2020). How TikTok changed the world in 2020. [online] www.bbc.com.

Price, H. (2019). TikTok activism: “We’re changing the world in 15 seconds.” [online] BBC Three.

The YouTubers who blew the whistle on an anti-vax plot. (2021). BBC News. [online] 24 Jul.

Williams, O. (2019). Virtual Influencers: The Future of Influencer Marketing? [online] Influencer Marketing.

McLaughlin, A. (2021). The future of virtual influencers. [online] Creative Review.

The Drum. (n.d.). The future of influencers: expect more virtual. [online]

www.virtualhumans.org. (n.d.). Who is Samsung Sam? Why Everyone is Excited for a Virtual Human that Doesn’t Exist Yet. [online]